Review of: The Finish: The Killing of Osama bin Laden
Author: Mark Bowden
Publisher: Atlantic Monthly Press
Source: Dallas Public Library
Grade: A
In retrospect, it sounds
nostalgically naïve: the notion that finding Osama bin Laden, the man behind
the 9/11 attacks, would signal the beginning of the end of terrorism. In an era
when bin Laden’s al Qaeda organization has been superseded by organizations
more vicious and fratricidal than anything bin Laden himself ever imagined, I
wondered if there were still any lessons the rest of us can learn from the
long, brutal search for the elusive Saudi jihadist. In The Finish: The Killing of Osama bin Laden, Mark Bowden, bestselling author of Black Hawk
Down, provides some answers to that question, as well as the most balanced
treatment I have seen of the hunt for bin Laden and its immediate aftermath.
Granted, when The Finish was published in 2012, there was still hope that the
popular uprisings of the Arab Spring would sweep away the dictators and
demagogues who had long plagued the Middle East. Hope that terrorism would wane
with the decimation of al Qaeda’s leadership by U.S. and coalition drones, and
the increasing disgust of Sunni adherents over attacks that killed far more
fellow Muslims than American soldiers.
And although those hopes have been
dashed, there were some lasting benefits from the long hunt, if only in
developing new ways to make war in the 21st century.
Bowden begins with a prologue: the
capture of a massive cache of information – references to “names, photos,
travel documents, expense reports for phone cards, clothing, vehicles, fuel,
money transfers, and many other detailed documents. . . For centuries, the
basic tactics of infantry warfare were ‘fire and maneuver’”. For this century, ‘information
and intelligence is the fire and maneuver.’” Cracking the captured data cache
helped solidify the importance of intelligence gathering and its analysis by
high-capability computers in the role of warfare.
Bowden also documents the
ideological evolution and eventual rise of Barack Obama following 9/11 and bin
Laden’s parallel rise from rich-kid financier of jihadis against the armies of
the Soviet Union in Afghanistan (and fall) to man on the run by the end of the
decade following the 9/11 attacks.
Meanwhile, beyond intelligence
gathering and analysis, the U.S. was developing two significant weapons against
bin Laden and al Qaeda, weapons that would prove their usefulness – and their
limitations – repeatedly.
One such set of weapons were the
remotely-piloted aircraft commonly known as drones. Their capabilities evolved
from long-term aerial spying into carriers of missiles able to hit target
s with
limited potential for loss of civilian life. And no physical danger at all to
their pilots, housed miles, even oceans away from where the drones were
deployed.
The other weapon was an array of
special operations forces whose “principles of the lightning raid – simple,
secret, and well rehearsed, executed with surprise, speed, and purpose” would
bring down bin Laden himself in his compound in Abbottabad, Pakistan. Until
little more than a month before the raid on May 1, 2011, Obama and his advisers
had debated whether to use a drone strike or special ops – in this case, a team
of Navy SEALS – to attack bin Laden. The decision went to the SEALS.
The raid itself, from the time
military helicopters flying from Afghanistan reached the Abbottabad compound,
until they look off again, took approximately 30 minutes. It left four men dead
-- bin Laden, one of his adult sons, and two other men living at the compound.
The wife of one of the men unrelated to bin Laden was also dead, and bin
Laden’s youngest wife was wounded. No Americans were injured.
In America, people danced in the
streets at the news of bin Laden’s death. Meanwhile, more would-be terrorists
waited, perhaps glad the old man was dead, but eager to snatch his bloody
mantle for themselves.
***
I've spent this week catching up on reading and reviews. Tomorrow, something lighter: Christopher Andersen's deliciously dishy Game of Crowns: Elizabeth, Camilla, Kate, and the Throne.
No comments:
Post a Comment