Showing posts with label seven sins of writing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label seven sins of writing. Show all posts

Friday, April 20, 2018

At the bottom of the deepest circle of revision hell

The opposite of love is not hate, it’s indifference. – Elie Wiesel
We have met the enemy, and he is us. -- Pogo
Finally, on our writer’s quest for redemption from The Seven Deadly First Page Sins (as devised by author/editors Tex Thompson and Laura Maisano), we have reached the end. That’s right, the lowest depths of revision hell. And the good news, once we reach bottom, there’s nowhere to go but up!
In Dante’s version of hell, the lowest circles were occupied not by the most lecherous or violent. Those sins, although deadly, he considered the ones most tied to our earthly, bodily nature. He reserved the lowest depths for the fraudulent, the seducers, the flatters. Those who sinned against our intellect, with the devil at the very bottom. Thompson and Maisano call their writerly version of these ultimate intellectual sins, the sins of indifference. Although the sinners of Dante were without hope, there is redemption for even the worst sins of a writer’s craft. But writer beware – the sins of indifference are the most difficult to repair.
In the interest of knowing the enemy (especially when she is us), Thompson/Maisano name the sins of indifference clichés, confusion and – worst and deadliest of all – boredom.
The problem with clichés is, they once worked so well! Like Lucifer, they originally bore the aspect of angels. Some were quick and easy forms of shorthand that packed a lot of information into small packages. Is that crystal clear? Plain as the nose on your face? Does it make you mad as a hatter? Do we even know what these tired phrases mean anymore? 
Some flattered us into the sins off excess with the lure of genre-specific clichés – endless, and endlessly trite descriptions of magic, romance, or bad behavior. 
image: pixabay
Some will try to insert themselves into any genre. Anyone who wants the full course on writerly sins will need to contact Thompson/Maisano (or have your writing group leader do so), so I’ll only provide snippets from their list of the tired but still filthily sinful “dirty dozen” of opening page clichés: character waking up, character addressing the audience, dream sequence, flash forward to something actually interesting from much later in the story (annoying prologue syndrome). 
Stop! I can hear readers crying. Didn’t Metamorphosis (1915) open with a character waking up? Didn’t David Copperfield (1850) and Catcher in the Rye (1951) open with a character addressing the audience? Didn’t Rebecca (1938) open with a dream sequence (not to mention flashing forward to an interesting event later in the story)? And weren’t they successful, now classic, tales?
Remember though, clichés weren’t born that way. They were tactics so brilliant that everybody and her dog used them. Only not so brilliantly. Notice the dates on those original stories – none of them are recent. And a century after Copperfield, the direct address to readers had become so banal that Catcher had to make a deliberate attempt to subvert it. Daphne du Maurier gets additional mileage from her dream opening in Rebecca by telling us directly that it’s a dream, not pulling any tricks. And though it’s also a flash forward, there’s actually even more interesting stuff in the book than the fate of an old mansion.

And for everyone whose critique group has told them never to open with a character waking up, I’ve got to say that waking up to find yourself transformed into a giant insect has got to be out of the ordinary course of a character’s life. It makes me wonder what Kafka’s critique group had to say about it.
Still, before anyone becomes too discouraged, Thompson/Maisano urge us to be as hopelessly dull and cliched as we like on our first drafts. Then . . . do something else.
“Take your first, second, and third ideas and place them carefully in the garbage!”
Clichés, though, aren’t the only sins of indifference. There’s also confusion (who did what to who and where and when?) Leaving questions in a reader’s mind can be a good thing. Or a bad thing.
Good if it makes the reader wonder what comes next, or whether the character will get what she wants, or even wonder what’s in that strangely shaped, ticking parcel? Questions go bad when the reader can’t picture the scene, doesn’t know who’s speaking, or who did what to whom.
And finally, the baddest of the bad, the greatest writerly sin of indifference is . . . boredom. 
Speaking to a meeting of Dallas Mystery Writers, Thompson warned that there is no way to completely boredom-proof a story. There will always be somebody who just doesn’t get it, just doesn’t care. We can, however, make our stories boredom-resistant, by providing them with a unique character, a daunting task, a strange place or thing, an intriguing mystery or an unexpected reversal. 
There’s not room in the opening pages for us to do justice to them all. Pick one and do it well. And save the rest for the rest of the pages of our book.
(Coming – revision doesn’t always need to be hell. One author/editor finds it the part of writing he enjoys most.)

Tuesday, April 17, 2018

Middle circles of revision hell: when excess turns deadly

Dante dubbed the middle circles of his map of hell the spots reserved for those who committed sins of violence and ambition. Populated by both hoarders and wasters, the wrathful and the sullen, the middle circles teemed with monsters.

In their modern take, writers/authors Tex Thompson and Laura Maisano term these mid-regions, more appropriately I think, the place for sins of excess. And while Dante adopted “abandon all hope” as the motto engraved over the gates, Thompson and Maisano undertake to guide writers bent on revision through these pitfalls and past the monsters waiting to snatch the unwary writers in their version of The Seven Deadly First Page Sins.

Even without a guide, writers can guess that the sins of the middle circles of writerly revision hell include excessive description. No matter how lovely it seems, too much description can be as deadly to readers as a Roman emperor’s shower of roses was to his dinner guests.

image: Wikipedia 
Assuming we’ve already checked our manuscripts for the early circle sin of wordiness, what else can we do when description pours forth in torrents from our pens (or word processors)? Taking as her example the classic “dark and stormy night” of Edward Bulwer-Lytton, Thompson urged us to find the key nouns, the most evocative verbs, and rewrite our Bulwer-esque passages to create a single powerful image.
Does this mean no adjectives? No adverbs? Not at all. But modifiers need to be used thriftily (no hoarding, no wasting!)

Middle circle sins also include excessive exposition (backstory), with each literary genre providing its unique temptations. Fantasy and science fiction allure us to expound on the history of wizards, wars and weaponry. Romance tells tempts us to describe the charms of the plain but alluring heroine. Crime fiction sneers that what we really need are paragraphs-long descriptions of mutilated bodies.
That last brings us to another sin of excess – too much action. I’m tempted to add, too much violent action. And that’s not just fights, but chases, heists, sex, and high-stakes games.

Wait, how can you have too much action? Aren’t we writers constantly told to open with the protagonist doing something? That action is how characters show us their, well, character? And aren’t all the too-much actions the basis of every James Bond movie’s opening sequence.
The answer is yes, but. Yes, we need action but too much can actually keep readers from caring about the character.

My personal test: although I love thrillers, if somebody is thrown off a cliff on the first page – and yes, I’ve seen this – the book goes back on the shelf, unread and unbought.

James Bond has earned the freedom to open with a James Bond sequences because audiences already love him. He’s paid his dues, and we know once he’s gone through his obligatory opening calisthenics, the real story can begin. As writers, our job is to make our audiences love our characters as much as they do 007.
How is a writer to know when she’s fallen into these sins of excess? One test, while we still have movies in mind, is whether her opening scene is filmable. If there’s too little happening, the problem may be excess description.

If, however, the opening scene is all choreography – only a list of actions – the writer has fallen into the sin of excessive action.
Characteristic reader reactions to sins of excess vary from “I didn’t know what the character wanted” to “exciting, but I didn’t really care” and even, “I skimmed/skipped ahead.”

“It’s a good idea to make your first chapter a sampler platter of what’s to come,” Thompson told her audience at the recent meeting of Dallas Mystery Writers. Some character, some action, some description. Don’t overload on any single ingredient!
Writerly redemption can be achieved by starting where the story actually starts (goodbye backstory!), provoking readers’ curiosity, and focusing on the unusual or unexpected in descriptions of people, persons or things. Use actions and descriptions that reveal character instead of concealing it.

(Are we ready yet to confront the lowest of the low? After we’ve shed the sins of the upper and middle circles of hell, prepare for the worst of all writing craft sins!)