Showing posts with label DFW Writers Conference. Show all posts
Showing posts with label DFW Writers Conference. Show all posts

Friday, October 2, 2026

Don't fear the gong at DFW Writers Conference

 It's the DFW Writers Conference (Oct. 3-4) in Hurst,, Texas, and for the first time in years, I have a conflict that keep me away from it. However, for those who will attend, one of the most-anticipated events is the Query Gong Show. So much so that the conference schedules it for first thing Sunday morning (8 a.m. CDT). Bring coffee!

If you're still hesitating to attend, you'll have to pay at the door. Advance registration is now closed. See the site for details.

For years, I've posted results of one of the most-anticipated events of the annual conference: the Query Gong Show. And done the post-mortems as one after another, writers of literary query letters heard their efforts go down to defeat.

Last year, I did a review version--reviewing what not to put in a query. So, for those who attend, here's the recap. Read this and, I hope, you will not weep.

For those who have never read this blog, and/or never been to a DFW Writers Conference, here are the Gong Show basics. Writers submit their anonymous query letters to a panel of agents and editors. These in turn, strike table-top gongs to signal the point at which they would stop reading if they received such a query in their own emails.

Right now, some readers are wondering, what the heck is a query letter?

In the literary sense, it's a business-like introduction from a writer to an agent asking if the agent is interested in representing the writer's work.

 The basic format includes:

  • brief description of why the writer chose to contact the agents ("your website. . . ", "you represent my favorite writer. . . ", etc.)
  • the book's title 
  • genre
  • manuscript word count
  • the story's "hook" (attention grabbing sentence)
  • brief summary (not including the ending, spoilers, etc.)
  • author's credentials, if any
The entire letter typically occupies no more than one page, approximately 300 words in single-spaced, 12 point(ish) sized type. This format is for works of fiction. Querying for nonfiction works is beyond the scope of this post.
Image: wikimedia commons


Now, back to the Gong Show basics.

Writers can be gonged once, even twice, by any panel member without stopping the reading of their letter. But three strikes and they're out!

What makes agents hit those dreaded gongs?

Some items stand out repeatedly. One is word count. Writers should have some clues about industry standards for their genre, especially for debut authors. At the first Gong Show, multiple simultaneous gongs sounded for a query which boasted 135,000 words. Luckily, the queries are anonymous. No one dashed from the room in tears.

Over time, writers have grown cannier about the word count issue. However, I was startled to hear agents carping about a 70,000-word entry for middle grade readers. "Middle grade" is a publishing term for readers aged approximately 9-12: those old enough to read independently.

Novels aimed at adult readers can easily hover around 80,000 words--higher for science fiction and fantasy works. Even classic middle grade novels such as the original Harry Potter clock in over 75,000. But lest we forget, the original Potter was published in 1997.

What's changed since then? A lot, especially since the pandemic, when many kids were out of school or at least only online for months. It's made a difference in reading ability. Not to mention attention spans. 

How far out of bounds was a book of 70,000 words last year? And possibly still is?

Ask a dozen agents, authors, and internet sites and you'll get two dozen answers. Writer's Digest cited 20-55K for middled grade, again, slightly higher for science fiction and fantasy.

WD also stated that middle grade word counts have been trending upward. Agents at recent DFW conferences say otherwise. That the opposite, in fact, is the case. Be aware if you're writing for younger audiences.

Another, even more common reason for agents to hit the gongs has shown little improvement over the years: taking too long to get to what one agent called "the beating heart of the story."

This is the "brief summary" mentioned earlier. It's not a synopsis. If the agent wants a synopsis with the query letter, they'll ask for it. Check their or their agency's websites for specifics.

The brief summary typically will extend for no more than two paragraphs. It should include:
  • main character
  • character's desire/goal
  • who or what stands in the way of achieving that goal (antagonist)
  • consequences of reaching the goal--or not (the stakes)
Although this list sounds generic, agents still asked writers to let their own voices shine through. Just not in multiple paragraphs.

I probably should mention that though the query itself is in the writer's first person, the summary should be in third person to avoid confusion about who's talking!

Less frequently mentioned but significant dislikes from agents were queries that failed to follow through on the expected tropes of their genre or leaned on generic descriptions. 

Also, use of trendy, cliched, or overblown language; opening with unlikeable characters, gross-out language, or depressingly sad situations; assuring the agent that the story is "intriguing" or "a good fit" for them (they like to decide that for themselves); querying for sequels or a book series (although some agents are OK with mentions that a book is a stand-alone with sequel/series potential); misspelling the agent's name (really!); and failure to exercise sensitivity about issues such as gender/ethnic stereotypes, disabilities, and racial language.

And while getting the agent's name right, consider checking the Ms./Mr. honorifics. These can be tricky, especially if the agent/editor hasn't indicated what they prefer, or if they're nonbinary individuals. Best advice, simply use "first name + last name" as indicated on the individual's or agency's website.

After last year's Gong Show, a writer unable to attend asked plaintively, "what do agents like?"

The specifics of what a particular agent likes are beyond the Gong Show's ability to answer. The first steps are checking the agent's website and Manuscript Wish List, if available.

Additional sources of information include:
  • Query Tracker, with lists of agents and links to their websites and other published information. The basic version is free, or pony up $25 annually for more info.
  • Publishers Marketplace, listing deals (sales) by the agent, their market performance, and more. $25/month or $10 for "Quick Pass" with more limited features. There's also a free Publishers Lunch version.
  • Your favorite authors. The acknowledgment sections of their books often list and thank their agents.
And although I haven't heard it addressed at the Gong Show, an issue agents at conferences often mention is that of comparative (comp) titles. These are books in your or similar genres, usually published with the past two to three years, with similarities to your manuscript.

That's not similarities of plot. As one agent said, if it's the same plot as something already published, why would I want it? Instead, the similarities can be in tone, setting or point of view. They also need to be books which have significant readership. This information gives agents an idea of where your book should be shelved in a bookshop, which in turn helps them pitch it to publishing house editors.

For readership information, check Amazon and Goodreads both free.

Finally remember all Gong Show queries are anonymous and not addressed to specific agents. Use the information from them to revise and send to appropriate agents. They probably won't even remember hearing the first version at the Gong Show! 

Monday, July 6, 2026

Scorching Texas temps signal fall literary events


 (Updated July 13 to include Richardson Reads One Book)

July temperatures in Texas are in the high-90’s with “feel-like” temps in the triple digits. Which is great news because – it means autumn’s on the way!

So, for the next few months, here are some literary events in the state to look forward to. But first, a couple of contest updates.

First: The Writer’s League of Texas reminds me their manuscript contest is still open. But only until July 10. Which I’m guessing means the League really, really wants to see our work. I even dug out an older manuscript, brushed it off and sent it in, with the promise of whether their editors loved it or hated the tar out of it, I’ll get feedback in September.

A couple of things in this contest were new to me, although possibly not to more recent participants. Usually, the entry form requests the first 10 pages of manuscript plus a synopsis. This time, the limit is 2,750 words INCLUDING synopsis. My advice – keep the synopsis as short as possible, using the format from my February 22, 2025, post “Writing a synopsis – the short road to a long tale.”

Check the WLT’s site for full details.

Second: Since I posted about the Laree Bryant Memorial Scholarship Contest sponsored by Dallas Mystery Writers the group has updated some of its requirements.

Previously, the contest was advertised as open to all fiction genres. DMW has now added “except erotica” to that list.  Also clarified is that entrants may not be traditionally or self-published in any form of fiction for the past year. That’s after September 5, 2025, for this year’s contest ending September 5, 2026.  Previous winners must wait three years to re-enter.

Unlike the WLT’s contest, there’s no entry fee for this one, and the winner receives a paid in full registration for the October 2026 Dallas-Fort Worth Writers Conference . Again, see my post, “Sunny days of writing & reading – plus a new writing contest,” for details. 

image from  Pixabay

Now, to upcoming events: 

Sept. 11-13: ArmadilloCon 2026, the sci-fi/fantasy/horror convention has a new hotel – Holiday Inn Austin Midtown, 6000 Middle Fiskville Rd. Other than that, it’s the same fan-run, fan-generated convention that’s been putting the “weird” in Austin since 1979.

Besides chances to hear and see favorite genre writers and artists, it includes a writers workshop on the 11th.

Early bird adult memberships are $80 or add the writing workshop for a total of $179, including Friday lunch and membership in the rest of the convention. See th-ole site for registration and special rates for student and child memberships.

Hotel reservations at convention rates are also available, but this is the weekend for the Texas v. Ohio State football game, so the hotel expects to sell out quickly.

Sept. 15: Richardson Reads One Book, the North Texas city's municipal-wide read-a-thon, returns with New York Times best-selling author Kate Messner's The Trouble with Heroes. The story follows 13-year-old Finn Collins, who lashed out at fate following the death of his father in the COVID pandemic by vandalizing the grave of a legendary woman mountain climber. The woman's daughter offers a surprising chance at redemption--if Finn can match the climber's record while accompanied by her dog.

Free online tickets for the author discussion available starting in September. Contact the Richardson Public Library at 972-744-4100 or at richardsonreadstx@gmail.com for more information.

Messner will appear at First United Methodist Church Richardson, 503 N. Central Expressway, Richardson, at 7: 30 p.m. Sept. 15. 

Sept. 23-27: Archer City Traditional Workshop, sponsored by the Larry McMurty Literary Center . is open to writers of nearly every genre  -- fiction, nonfiction narratives, memoir, history, features (even poetry and songwriting!) at all levels of experience. At the Spur Hotel, 110 North Center Street, in Archer City, with opportunities to visit McMurtry’s former “Booked Up” bookstore and the home of the Larry McMurtry Literary Center. See the site for detailed information, itinerary and registration.

Cost: $795 by Sept. 1, $895 thereafter, $100 non-refundable deposit required upon first registration. Fee includes lodging and even meals Wednesday through Saturday. 

For hotel questions or questions about Archer City, contact Kathy Floyd at kfloyd@lmcmurtrylitcenter.org.

Sept. 30 – Oct. 4: The Larry McMurtry Literary Center also sponsors the workshop, Writing Dynamic Memoir: From Lived Experience to Gripping Story, with instructors Ronin Plank and Glenn Stout. Also at  the Spur Hotel in Archer City.

Ronit Plank is a writer, teacher and editor whose work has appeared in The Atlantic, The New York Times and numerous other venues. Glenn Stout is the author, editor or ghostwriter of more than 100 books for both adult and  juvenile audiences.

Cost: $1,395 by Sept. 1, $1,495 thereafter, with $100 non-refundable deposit. Fee includes lodging and evening meals Wednesday through Sunday. See the site (www.lmcmurtrylitcenter.org)  to register.

For hotel questions or questions about Archer City, contact Kathy Floyd at kfloyd@lmcmurtrylitcenter.org.

Oct. 3-4: DFW Writers Conference returns to the Hurst Convention Center, 1601 Campus Dr., Hurst, TX. Lots of programming and a ticket buys one chance to pitch to the agent or editor of your choice (while time permits).

Regular registration through September 20, $449. Regular one-day registration through Sept. 20, $250. Late registration Sept. 21-Oct. 1, $499 (two-day) and $299 (one-day). See the site  for registration and additional information. Or add on the pre-con Pitch Perfect Workshop, Oct.2 for $20.

Hotel reservations at the adjoining Hilton Garden Inn are also available at convention rates while space is available.

Oct. 16-18: Hay Festival Forum Dallas 2026 presents writers, musicians and activists in conversations, performances and book clubs across the Bishop Arts District in Dallas.

Limited information so far, but Hay Festival Forum Dallas will highlight over 25 artist and 30 events. Now in its eighth year, this will be the largest and most inclusive Forum yet, offering big stage conversations, workshops and book clubs in venues across the city, including The Texas Theatre, Dallas Public Library, Whose Books, Oak Cliff Assembly, and The Wild Detectives bookstore.

The bilingual program promises a world of different perspectives, celebrating the range of backgrounds, languages, and experiences represented by its guests, while bridging the border with local writing stars and headline names from further afield.

Nov. 14-15: The Texas Book Festival returns for venues at the state capitol and around Austin! Stay tuned to the site for more details.

 

Thursday, April 2, 2026

Some fast & furious updates: contests and conferences

 Sometime ago, I promised an update on the Writer's League of Texas manuscript contest. It's finally arrived! The contest is open now through July 10. This means winners will not be able to meet in-person with a literary agent during the WLT's 2026 Agents & Editors Conference June 26-28. More on this later.

First, though, this Saturday, April 4 is a chance to meet -- free! -- agent Sandy Lu of Book Wyrm Literary Agency. And, for writers in North Central Texas, without hours long travel.

Sandy Lu is the guest speaker at the Dallas Mystery Writers meeting, 10:15 a.m. to noon, at Olive Garden, 4240 Belt Line (at Midway) in Addison, Texas. OK, I said free, but there is a $10 fee (cash only, please bring small bills) for non-members for the program and drinks-only attendees. The fee is reduced to $5 (again, cash only) for non-members staying for lunch. The program is followed by pay-your-own lunch, or just stay and break breadsticks with fellow writers.

As far as I can tell, Lu will not be available for book pitches at the meeting but see her site or contact james@gaskin.com for additional information. 

***

Image: wikimedia commons

Back to the WLT manuscript contest. It's open for unpublished manuscripts by writers in or out of Texas, in a variety of fiction and nonfiction genres. The winner in each category will meet virtually with a top literary agent (and the final judge in their category) via Zoom. All entrants who opt for a critique, whether winners or not, will receive feedback on their submissions from an experienced editor. 

All 2026 winners and finalists will be featured in the fourth edition of the WLT Inklist, a catalog of short pitches shared with literary agents and book editors in Fall 2026.

Manuscript entry fees are $65 for WLT members/$85 for nonmembers (which includes a written critique. Fees for contestants who opt out of written critiques are $25 for WLT members, $35 for nonmembers.

Contestants may enter as many categories as they like, with up to four entries per category. Each entry requires separate payment and entry form.

Winners and finalists will be notified by mid-October 2026. Any submissions that include a critique will receive their written feedback by mid-September 2026. After winners and finalists are notified, all other submissions will receive emails of the judging results.

Again, refer to the site for additional details, formatting rules, categories, etc.

Also, see the WLT site for information about its Agents & Editors Conference in Austin, Texas, including a list of featured agents and editors. Registration: $549 for WLT members, $599 for nonmembers. Pitch/consultation sessions with literary agents and editors available for purchase as space allows. 

***

Also coming up later this year is the DFW Writers Conference, October 3-4, at the Hurst Convention Center, Hurst, Texas. Registration through September 20 is $449 for both days. Registration includes one complimentary session with a literary agent or editor. See the site for additional information and list of agents/editors so far!

Saturday, September 27, 2025

Beat DFWcon's gong: the query gong, that is

For years, I've posted results of one of the most-anticipated events of the annual DFW Writers Conference: the Query Gong Show. And done the post-mortems as one after another, writers of literary query letters heard their efforts go down to defeat.

Last year, I did a review version--reviewing what not to put in a query. So, here goes again. Read this and, I hope, you will not weep.

For those who have never read this blog, and/or never been to a DFW Writers Conference, here are the Gong Show basics. Writers submit their anonymous query letters to a panel of agents and editors. These in turn, strike table-top gongs to signal the point at which they would stop reading if they received such a query in their own emails.

Right now, some readers are wondering, what the heck is a query letter?

In the literary sense, it's a business-like introduction from a writer to an agent asking if the agent is interested in representing the writer's work.

 The basic format includes:

  • brief description of why the writer chose to contact the agents ("your website. . . ", "you represent my favorite writer. . . ", etc.)
  • the book's title 
  • genre
  • manuscript word count
  • the story's "hook" (attention grabbing sentence)
  • brief summary (not including the ending, spoilers, etc.)
  • author's credentials, if any
The entire letter typically occupies no more than one page, approximately 300 words in single-spaced, 12 point(ish) sized type. This format is for works of fiction. Querying for nonfiction works is beyond the scope of this post.

Now, back to the Gong Show basics.

Writers can be gonged once, even twice, by any panel member without stopping the reading of their letter. But three strikes and they're out!

What makes agents hit those dreaded gongs?

Some items stand out repeatedly. One is word count. Writers should have some clues about industry standards for their genre, especially for debut authors. At the first Gong Show, multiple simultaneous gongs sounded for a query which boasted 135,000 words. Luckily, the queries are anonymous. No one dashed from the room in tears.

Over time, writers have grown cannier about the word count issue. However, last year I was startled to hear agents carping about a 70,000-word entry for middle grade readers. "Middle grade" is a publishing term for readers aged approximately 9-12: those old enough to read independently.

Novels aimed at adult readers can easily hover around 80,000 words--higher for science fiction and fantasy works. Even classic middle grade novels such as the original Harry Potter clock in over 75,000.

How far out of bounds was a book of 70,000 words?

Ask a dozen agents, authors, and internet sites and you'll get two dozen answers. Writer's Digest cited 20-55K for middled grade, again, slightly higher for science fiction and fantasy.

WD also stated that middle grade word counts have been trending upward. Agents at the 2024 DFW said otherwise. That the opposite, in fact, is the case. I won't detail the reasons for this drop but be aware if you're writing for younger audiences.

Another, even more common reason for agents to hit the gongs has shown little improvement over the years: taking too long to get to what one agent called "the beating heart of the story."

This is the "brief summary" mentioned earlier. It's not a synopsis. If the agent wants a synopsis with the query letter, they'll ask for it. Check their or their agency's websites for specifics.

The brief summary typically will extend for no more than two paragraphs. It should include:
  • main character
  • character's desire/goal
  • who or what stands in the way of achieving that goal (antagonist)
  • consequences of reaching the goal--or not (the stakes)
Although this list sounds generic, agents still asked writers to let their own voices shine through. Just not in multiple paragraphs.

I probably should mention that though the query itself is in the writer's first person, the summary should be in third person to avoid confusion about who's talking!

Less frequently mentioned but significant dislikes from agents were queries that failed to follow through on the expected tropes of their genre or leaned on generic descriptions. 

Also, use of trendy, cliched, or overblown language; opening with unlikeable characters, gross-out language, or depressingly sad situations; assuring the agent that the story is "intriguing" or "a good fit" for them (they like to decide that for themselves); querying for sequels or a book series (although some agents are OK with mentions that a book is a stand-alone with sequel/series potential); misspelling the agent's name (really!); and failure to exercise sensitivity about issues such as gender/ethnic stereotypes, disabilities, and racial language.

And while getting the agent's name right, consider checking the Ms./Mr. honorifics. These can be tricky, especially if the agent/editor hasn't indicated what they prefer, or if they're nonbinary individuals. Best advice, simply use "first name + last name" as indicated on the individual's or agency's website.

Image: Wikimedia


After last year's Gong Show, a writer unable to attend asked plaintively, "what do agents like?"

The specifics of what a particular agent likes are beyond the Gong Show's ability to answer. The first steps are checking the agent's website and Manuscript Wish List, if available.

Additional sources of information include:
  • Query Tracker, with lists of agents and links to their websites and other published information. The basic version is free, or pony up $25 annually for more info.
  • Publishers Marketplace, listing deals (sales) by the agent, their market performance, and more. $25/month or $10 for "Quick Pass" with more limited features. There's also a free Publishers Lunch version.
  • Your favorite authors. The acknowledgment sections of their books often list and thank their agents.
And although I haven't heard it addressed at the Gong Show, an issue agents at conferences often mention is that of comparative (comp) titles. These are books in your or similar genres, usually published with the past two to three years, with similarities to your manuscript.

That's not similarities of plot. As one agent said, if it's the same plot as something already published, why would I want it? Instead, the similarities can be in tone, setting or point of view. They also need to be books which have significant readership. This information gives agents an idea of where your book should be shelved in a bookshop, which in turn helps them pitch it to publishing house editors.

For readership information, check Amazon and Goodreads both free.

Finally remember all Gong Show queries are anonymous and not addressed to specific agents. Use the information from them to revise and send to appropriate agents. They probably won't even remember hearing the first version at the Gong Show! 

Tuesday, October 8, 2024

DFWCon word limit caution -- plus, the Gong Show

 I settled in the auditorium of the DFW Writers Conference  early Sunday morning for the annual query Gong Show. This is the event iin which writers submit their anonymous literary queries to a panel of agents and editors, who strike table-top gongs to signal the point at which they would stop the read if receiving such a query in their own emails.

As I hoped against hope not to hear a repeat of the usual agents' complaints, something new startled me. The word counts cited in some of the entries.

After several years of relentless gonging at this contest, canny writers know opening with a 135,000-ish word count is a nonstarter.

What startled me out of an insufficiently caffeinated daze was carping about a 70,000-word entry for middle grade readers. "Middle grade" is a publishing term for readers aged approximately 9-12 -- those old enough to read independently.

Novels aimed at adult readers can easily hover around 80,000 words -- higher for science fiction and fantasy works. Even classic middle grade novels such as the original Harry Potter clock in at over 75,000. 

How far out of bounds was a book of 70,000 words?

Ask a dozen agents, authors, and internet sites and you'll get two dozen answers. Writer's Digest, in a post updated in 2021, cites 20-55K for middle grade, with slightly higher word counts for science fiction and fantasy works.

Image: wikimedia

WD also states that middle grade word counts have been trending up lately.

But agents at DFW said otherwise. That the opposite, in fact, is the case.

The reason -- the pandemic shutdowns of many schools that hit when the middle graders of 2024 were barely beginning their journeys as fluent, independent readers.

Shutdowns of in-person learning, hopefully saved lives. But coupled with Zoom classes and other online learning venues, they hit younger readers at a uniquely vulnerable point in their development. Conference agents expected to see the lower-word-count issue follow into YA (young adult) books as readers who were in elementary school during the pandemic reach their teens.

Will the trend eventually age out? We're waiting to see. In the meantime, authors of books for young readers need to be particularly aware of their needs.

Oh, and those doorstop-sized Harry Potters? Besides getting extra word leeway for being a fantasy, it was first published nearly a quarter-century ago. To a readership who were only getting their first taste of the internet.

***

Now, a return to the rest of the Gong Show results.

DFW reader George Goldthwaite zipped through 11 randomly chosen, rapidly gonged queries before hitting paydirt with number 12, whose breathless author rose to take a bow.

Otherwise, too many authors -- not paying attention to this blog's repeated warnings -- spent far too much of their query on synopsis-like plot descriptions.

One query made it almost to the end before being hopelessly gonged, but even that ran to a second page. (Repeat after me: one page, 300 words max.)

Aside from the middle grade hopeful, writers were generally good at stating the word count and genre of their stories. However, more than once queries failed to follow through on the expected tropes of their genre or leaned on generic descriptions. Other dislikes involved talking down to the agent (and potential readers): "I don't need time travel explained to me."

And the ultimate, never, ever -- an entry beginning, "This is the query you have been waiting for!" The author may well have intended this opening to be funny, but it triggered multiple simultaneous clanging of gongs.

(Host Russell C. Connor admitted he had once, no doubt long, long ago, submitted a query with a similar opening. And was gonged. Whoever the unlucky author was, they were not alone.)

Agents did offer positive suggestions such as:

  • Color-coding words, allowing authors to visualize repeated ones and remove them
  • Reading lots of back cover blurbs for suggestions on what works in a query -- remembering, "all we need is an effective hook and a pitch"
  • Allowing the author's unique voice to shine
***

Next: There's more to come from the DFW conference. But first, a chance to catch up on autumn literary events that didn't make it into earlier posts.

Thursday, October 3, 2024

How not to fear DFW Con's query Gong Show

 So, did vitally important Texas literary events get left out of my previous post? You bet! Will the omissions be rectified? Maybe. But not until the still more vital prepping for the DFW Writers
Conference's (DFW Writers Conference) (in)famous Gong Show takes place. 

Sure, I post about this in its aftermath. But what writers really need to know now, now, RIGHT NOW! is what's going to happen. This Sunday, October 6, at 8 a.m.

For those who have never read this blog, and/or never been to a DFW conference, here are the basics of the Gong Show. Writers submit their anonymous literary query letters to a panel of agents and editors who strike table-top gongs to signal the point at which they would stop reading if they received one of these queries in their own emails.

Image: Pixabay

OK, maybe some readers are now wondering, what the heck is a query letter?

Here's the PSA: In the literary sense, it's a business-like introduction from a writer to an agent asking whether the agent is interested in representing the writer's work.

The basic format includes a brief description of why the writer chose to contact the agent ("your website. . . "), ("you represent my favorite writer. . . " etc.); the title, genre, and word count of the author's manuscript; the story's "hook" (attention grabbing sentence), and a brief summary; and the author's credentials, if any.

The entire letter typically occupies no more than one page -- approximately 300 words in email format.

Now, back to the Gong Show basics.

Writers can be gonged once, even twice, by any panel members without stopping the reading. But three strikes and they're out!

What are frequent triggers of the dreaded gongs? 

  • Generic, trendy, cliched, or overblown language
  • Opening with unlikeable characters, gross-out language, or depressingly sad situations
  • Assuring the agent that the story is "intriguing," or a "good fit" for them. (They like to decide that for themselves.)
  • Querying for sequels or a book series (although some agents are OK with mentions that a book is stand-alone with sequel/series potential)
  • Misspelling the agent's name. (Really!)
  • Spending too much word space on plot
A few quirks: at the 2023 Gong Show, although panelists realized entrants had no idea who they would be addressing in the contest, the salutation "Dear Agent" hit sore spots for those who've received too many similarly addressed queries too many times. Expect this issue to be addressed in the 2024 edition of the show.

Honorifics can also be tricky, especially if the agent/editor has not indicated which they prefer, or if they are nonbinary individuals. Best advice, once writers have selected an actual agent to address, is to simply use "first name + last name" as indicated on the individual's or agency's website.

What will stay the hand of a panelist itching for the gong?
  • Getting to the point! An agent last year suggested using no more than two short paragraphs to describe the "heart of the story." (And no, you don't need to tell the ending.)
  • Telling the "stakes" of the story -- main character, their goal, who/what they must overcome to achieve that goal, and the consequences of reaching that goal -- or not.
  • Listing the story's genre and word count. (If unsure of appropriate word counts, numerous information sources are available online, including Reedsy's How many words in a novel. If unsure about the story's genre, check where it would be shelved in a bookstore, or what genres are included in its description on sites such as Amazon and Goodreads.)
  • Exercising sensitivity about issues such as gender/ethnic stereotypes, disabilities, and racial language
***
After last year's Gong Show, a writer unable to attend asked plaintively, what do agents like?

Aside from the listed items, the specifics of what a particular agent likes are beyond the Gong Show's ability to answer. It depends, obviously, on the agent. The first steps are checking the agent's website and Manuscript Wish List if available.

Additional sources of information include:
  •  Query Tracker, offering lists of agents and links to their websites and other published information. The basic version is free, or pony up $25 annually for more info.
  • Publisher's Marketplace, listing deals (sales) by the agent, their market performance, and more. $25/month or $10 for "Quick Pass" with more limited features. There's also a free Publisher's Lunch version.
  • Your favorite authors. The acknowledgement sections of their books often list their agents.
Addendum: Although I've never heard it addressed at the Gong Show, an issue that agents at conferences often mention is that of "comparative (comp) titles." These are books in your or similar genres, usually published within the past two to three years, with similarities to your own.

That's not similarities of plot. As one agent has said, if it's the same plot as something already published, why would I want it? Instead, the similarities can be in tone, setting or point of view. They also need to be books which have significant readership.

For readership info, check Amazon, Goodreads, and USA Today -- all free. (I previously posted that the USA Today site was on hiatus but -- it's back!)

Got it? See you Sunday! 

Thursday, September 19, 2024

Fall in Texas, y'all -- football, fairs & writing

 I feel like Rip Van Winkle -- as if I've slept since last posting here in January. All I can say is, it's been a year: multiple international trips (not necessarily for fun stuff), as well as typical Texas weather -- monsoon rains followed by months of hellish heat, both with power outages.

But TGIF -- which in Texas means, thank God it's fall, with its abundance of literary events. Most of these listings are in the state, particularly in my corner of North Texas. But if there's something particularly juicy in another region, I'll dish it up too, starting this weekend.

September 21: The Writer's League of Texas presents Texas Writes with free workshops by authors Alex Temblador ("Prep Your Book: Going from Idea to Opening Pages") and Diana Spechler ("Writing Our Lives: The Art of the Personal Essay"). At Chico Public Library (that's north of Fort Worth), 106 W. Jacksboro St., Chico, TX. 10 a.m. - 1 p.m. Refreshments provided. Free. Pre-register by calling the library at (940) 644-2330.

Now-December 1: The Historical Novel Society North America presents its first short story contest. In honor of the society's 205 conference setting in Las Vegas, entries must be set in or around Vegas at any time up to 1975. Stories must be historical, but any subgenre is acceptable. Unpublished stories only, with a 4,000-word limit. Entry fee $25. Cash prizes and anthology publication for finalists and grand prize winner, chosen by a panel of best-selling historical fiction writers. See the site for details.

September 24: Richardson Reads One Book presents author Brendan Slocumb ("Symphony of Secrets") at 7:30 p.m. in First United Methodist Church Richardson, 503 N. Central Expressway, Richardson. Free, but tickets are only available online, on a first-come, first-served basis at bit.ly/RROBLecture24.

September 25: Dallas indie bookstore The Wild Detectives, 314 W. Eighth St., hosts "Banned Book Trivia," 7-9 p.m. Assemble a team and grab a beverage from the bookstore's bar as you test your knowledge of banned books. There's a general discussion of book bans, including Dallas' favorites, to bring you up to date! Free, except for food and drink selections.

October 4-6: Houston Writers Guild hosts the AuthorPalooza conference with craft workshops, industry panels, and literary fun! A few acquisition editors will also be available October 5 (Saturday) to take pitch sessions. Events at Rick University, 6100 Main St., Ley Student Conference Center. See the site for schedule and tickets.

October 5-6: The DFW Writers Conference at the Hurst Convention Center, Hurst, TX, offers craft and business workshops and panels, keynote speakers Steve Berry and A.S. King, and literary agents from around the country. Registration includes one free pitch selling, with additional sessions offered for sale.

This year's agenda also includes a Romance Forum, with a panel of New York Times best-selling authors. See the site for schedules. Regular registration (ends September 22!) is $449 for both days or $250 for one day. Late registration through October 4 is $99 (two day) or $299 (one day).

The adjacent Hilton Garden Inn is sold out, but other nearby hotels include Hampton Inn Suites Dallas, Holiday Inn Express & Suites DFW, and Hyatt Place Fort Worth/Hurst. Or drive in. Traffic should be less than fiendishly awful on a weekend.

October 11-13: HAY Festival Forum Dallas 2024 returns to the city's Bishop Arts District with 25 artists across 21 events over four venues! The festival includes both free and ticketed options. Opening night at the Wild Detectives bookstore, 314 E. Eighth St., opens with a free session by Pulitzer Prize winning author Viet Thanh Nguyen. See the site for a complete list of events. Day passes which ensure admission to all ticketed and free events are $85 for October 12 (Saturday), $65 for October 13 (Sunday, or $100 for an all-weekend pass.

November 13: Dallas indie bookstore Interabang Books presents best-selling author Malcolm Gladwell in conversation with Krys Boyd of KERA's Think. At Highland Park United Methodist Church, 3300 East Mockingbird, Dallas, 7 p.m. Tickets are free, although seating is limited, or $32 for exclusive "meet and greet" with the author. Gladwell will share his new book, Revenge of the Tipping Point. Books for sale which supplies last. See the site for ticket purchases/reservations.


***

Want more? Of course you do! Stay tuned for these and other Texas literary events!

Friday, September 8, 2023

Writing contests, classes & conferences: welcome to fall!

 What a summer it's been! I'm back from the hades that is summer in Texas, amazed at how good it felt recently to have days when the temperature didn't top 101 degrees F. (What we in the Lone Star State call a "cool spell.") Even cooler, the new season come with a fresh list of writing conferences, classes and contests. I'm partial to Texas-related events but sometimes include others, especially if they're online.

First: the contests:

Now-Oct. 15: Pulp Literature's Raven Short Story Contest for unpublished short fiction (500-2,500 words). No need to include birds but hurry, total entries are limited to 200. Early bird entry fee (before September 15) $15, regular entry fee $20. Or add an editorial critique for $25. 

Now-Oct. 24: A Texas contest! The Kathryn McClatchy Flash Fiction Contest sponsored by the Writers Guild of Texas. Entries must be unpublished, with word counts between 300-1,000. Limited to WGT members but for a fee of $35, non-members receive a one-year membership as well as entry into the contest. Cash prizes for first through fourth (honorable mention) winners. See the site for details, including format and judging criteria.

Now-Oct. 31: How about, from across the pond, Flash 500's Novel Opening & Synopsis Competition? For novels, whether started or completed, with strong, credible characters, page-turning plots and compelling synopsis. Send first chapters (up to first 3,000 words) of unpublished works only, plus synopsis. Cash prizes. Entry fees: £10 for one novel, £18 for two, £26 for three. Online payment methods will happily translate these amounts into dollars. See the site for details.

Oct. 1-mid-Nov.: Carve Magazine's Prose & Poetry Contest seeks the best literary fiction, nonfiction and poetry. Carve is based in Dallas, Texas, but accepts writers from all over the world. Cash prizes in each genre, with winners published in the magazine's spring issue. See the site for details.

Dec. 1: Still missing the now-retired PitMad? Don't be sad! Try Cam Cat Books version on X (formerly known as Twitter). Check out details at www.twitter.com, #CamCatPitMad.

Want more contests? Check out lists from Publishing. . . and Other Forms of Insanity, Writer's Digest, Reedsy and Writers of the Future.

***

Now, about polishing the craft, pitching, networking, and just plain loving the whole writing and literature thing with Conferences and Classes:

Sept. 9-10: Hay Forum Dallas, at indie bookstore The Wild Detectives, 314 W. 8th St., Dallas, features writers from several Latin American countries as well as the United States. The format is based on the original festival at Hay-on-Why, Wales, which has since branched across Europe and Latin America. Free. RSVP at the site for times and details. 

Sept. 13 (repeating monthly): Another Texas goodie from Dallas Writers Garret and The Wild Detectives -- a monthly poetry series. RSVP at The Wild Detectives site for an evening with featured writer Christine Suggs, followed by a brief open mic session.

Sept. 16: Indie bookstore The Dock in Fort Worth celebrates National Literacy Month with the Trinity River Book Festival, featuring more than 20 local and national authors plus other family-friendly events. At Trinity River Pavilion 1, across from Chuy's Restaurant, West 7th St., Fort Worth.  See the site for details.

Now-Nov. 28: Arts & Letters Live continues its literary and performing arts series, sponsored by the Dallas Museum of Art. Guest speakers include Jonatha Eig, Barbara Kingsolver, Mary Beard, Jesmyn Ward, Zadie Smith and more. Ticket prices and venues vary. See the site for details.

Sept. 26: Richardson Reads One Book Author Lecture at 7:30 p.m., in First United Methodist Church, Richardson, 503 N. Central Expressway in Richardson, Texas, showcases Shelby Van Pelt's Remarkably Bright Creatures. Free, or add on an author interview and luncheon at the University of Texas at Dallas Davidson-Gundy Alumni Center. See the site for details, including how to secure free tickets for the lecture and purchases for the interview and luncheon.

Image: Carlos Villada for Pixabay 
Oct. 7-8: The DFW Writers Conference offers more than 50 classes, 12+ agents and editors, and guest speakers Dave Eggers and Evangeline Lilly, at the Hurst Conference Center, 1601 Campus Dr., Hurst, Texas. See the site for full agenda and tickets.

Nov. 1-30: Neither a class nor a conference, but NaNoWriMo offers a full month of incentives to finish that first draft of a novel. Free. See site for details, including ways to become involved locally and with other writers.

Nov. 11-12: The Texas Book Festival in Austin includes national and regional authors such as Ann Patchett, Abraham Verghese, Time magazine editor Walter Isaacson, political leader Stacey Abrams, and more! Free. See the site for details and venues throughout downtown Austin.

Dec. 9-10: The last few years were big on virtual conferences and the online format's become a staple. So, I can't resist mentioning the Writer's Digest University Historical Fiction virtual conference. Contents include webinar presentations from six award-winning, best-selling historical fiction authors, query letter feedback, and more. See the site for cost and details. 

In there more? Yes, indeed! The Writers League of Texas offers numerous classes both in person and online. See the site for details.

***

Still to come: Stuff I learned while it was too hot to post!

Monday, January 30, 2023

Reverse engineering a mystery -- in the end is the beginning

 Some writers are plotters, some are seat-of-the-pantsers. But if we're going to write whodunnits, one thing we must know from the beginning is -- who done it. So, at last fall's DFW Writers Conference, I marked the Reverse-Outline Your Way to an Unputdownable Mystery class by Jessica S. Olson as a must-attend.

Determined to expand her writing chops, Olson told us she had typed "how to write a mystery" into Google, only to find its answers completely unhelpful. She realized she'd have to solve the mystery of mystery writing on her own.

Like a good sleuth, she performed interrogations -- this time, of herself.

Q. What were the things she loved about mysteries?

A. Sleuths! And a puzzle to be solved. And of course, a good villain, aka, perpetrator. And ticking time bombs. And clues. And the opposite of clues -- red herrings. And of course, how to put them all together. All leading to The Big Reveal, which had to be big enough to justify the rest.

So, Olson started with the crime. Not with the weather, not even the world building. In effect, start with The Big Reveal -- but for now keep that a secret from everyone but yourself at this point, dear writer. Know the ending before writing the beginning. This means knowing:

  • What happened?
  • Who was the victim?
  • The perpetrator?
  • Why did the crime happen?
  • Where, how and what clues were left behind?
  • And of course -- who's the main character (sleuth)?
In most mysteries written for adult and even teen audiences, the happening will be a murder. But it can also be a theft, a disappearance/kidnapping, an act of espionage, assault, extortion, and more. 

The volume How to Write A Mystery: A Handbook from Mystery Writers of America, also has discussions of possible nonviolent "crimes" or puzzles that can propel mysteries for younger readers. However, Olson notes that the happening, whatever it is, must involve something compelling enough to be worth investigation, and for teens and older readers, must involve enough components to build a novel-length plot.

The victim(s) must also be compelling in their own right. If a mystery contains multiple victims, they need to be connected but also may point to multiple suspects.

Image: Pixabay
The writer will probably also have an idea of the main character's identity -- amateur or professional -- how they became entangled in the crime and why it's meaningful to them. Even if the sleuth is a professional, it's not enough that they've been hired to do a job (if a private investigator) or assigned to a case (if law enforcement personnel). And if the main character is an amateur sleuth, the mystery must be something that can only be solved by that person.

Then there's the perpetrator. Who are they and why did they do the crime? This person needs to be as fully developed as the main character, avoiding cliches as much as possible. Preferably, the perpetrator will be stronger, smarter, and better than the main character, who will have to strain every resource of brain -- and possibly brawn -- they possess to outwit the criminal.

Knowing what happened, who did it, and to whom, are essential to what Olson termed "the backwards treasure hunt" that that entails compiling lists of:
  • Clues
  • Red herrings (misdirections) and dead ends
  • People the main character can suspect
  • People the readers can suspect (these last two don't necessarily overlap)
Clues must be in places the main character can access -- although not necessarily easy of access; and plausible but not necessarily obvious. They should be found in a variety of locations and include details of where and how the crime was discovered and the testimony of witnesses (who also may not be easy of access).

With these details in mind, the writer can form a rough idea -- not yet set in stone -- of what the actual plot will entail. And deal with the fun parts of building the world of the story and the characters of both sleuth and villain. Not to mention laying out that Big Reveal that will make all the work worthwhile.

I'm not going to tell you everything Olson covered in her class. For that, see her
site
(www.jessicasolson.com) for questions, insider information, and the location of her next conference. But I will leave with her final admonition: "Read as many mysteries as you can. Find out what worked in those you love, or if less than loved, what went wrong." 

In other words, we must be our own sleuths.

***
Next up: Do you know you may have an author's page you never set up? I didn't -- until I got hit over the head with it! 

Tuesday, July 19, 2022

Post-pandemic writing conferences and contests revive

Are we experiencing a break in the pandemic clouds? So many literary events have restarted since my last posting, I'm in a hurry to catch up. Here's a rundown of Texas-centric in-person events for late summer into fall as well as virtual events and contests open no matter where you live:

July 23: Writers loved last year's virtual conference of the Historical Novel Society North America so much, the society announces a one-day virtual event this Saturday (July 23). Registration is $49, closing July 22. See the site for details.

Now-July 31: DL Hammons' reader-favorite WRiTE CLUB contest has had suffered from a decline in entries during the last two years of the COVID pandemic, and numbers this year were not sufficient to support the contest as envisioned. Here's hoping for a return for 2023!

August 5-7: ArmadilloCon, a science fiction/fantasy convention, will be in-person at Austin Southpark Hotel, Austin, Texas. Registration $65. Entries for the writing workshop are closed but still plenty of chances to meet and hear some of the best science fiction and fantasy writers in the business.

Now - September 30: L. Ron Hubbard's season Writers of the Future Contest for new writers of science fiction and fantasy. No entry fee, cash prizes. See the site for details.

September 16-18: FenCon, the Dallas-area science fiction/fantasy convention returns in-person at the Sheraton DFW Airport hotel, In Irving Texas. Early bird memberships for adults are $45 through September 1. FenCon will not hold its usual writing workshop this year (2022) but holds out hope for 2023.

October 8-9: Also returning in-person (for the first time in three years) is the DFW Writers Conference at the Hurst Conference Center in Hurst, Texas. Three-day registration through September 15 is $399 which includes one free pitch session to an agent or editor. Details about agents/editors and classes still to come.

Upcoming:

October 1-mid-November: Dallas-based Carve Magazine's Prose & Poetry Contest offers winners cash prizes and publication. I'll update as more information comes available.

***

Some of my favorite contests and events bit the dust for reasons pandemic or otherwise. Pitch Wars and Twitter-fav PitMad are no more. The Writers Guild of Texas has yet to post its annual fall flash fiction contest, although I still have hopes of seeing it now that the Guild is meeting in-person. Writers Organzations 'Round Dallas WordFest event also seems to be on hiatus, although it managed a virtual event earlier in the pandemic.

I'll be back closer to fall to see what goodies cooler weather may bring to life. In the meantime, a number of sites are always available online and always free to search for contests and other writing events:

Reedsy offers a pick of 2022's best writing contests, searchable by genre.

Arthur Klepchukov's seasonal listings, now of Fiction Writing Contests Worth Your Time in Summer 2022 are always worthwhile.

Erica Verrillo's continues her monthly gathering of conferences, contests, publishers and agents at Publishing and Other Forms of Insanity.

Ralan.com also offers searchable listings of writing outlets, including contests.

(Updated to show cancellation of WRiTE CLUB contest.)

Thursday, December 31, 2020

2020 countdown of readers’ favorite posts and blastoff!

DL Hammons annual WRiTE CLUB readers’ choice contest garners attention each spring. I contacted DL (full disclosure – he’s one of my critique partners) and at this time, he’s still planning to a 2021 production. Thankfully, it’s all online! The following post is based on comments of the contests slushpile readers as of April 2020, so things may change in a few months. Also, one of the perks of the contest is a chance for recognition at the annual conference hosted by the DFW Writers Workshop. In 2020, the conference fell victim to the pandemic, and as of this month’s DFWWW board meeting, its fate is still undecided. Here’s hoping the pandemic will have waned by the 2021 conference dates, June 12-13.    

What WRiTE CLUB slushpile readers want to see! 

It’s crunch time for submissions to the 2020 edition (and ninth year!) of DL Hammons WRiTE CLUB contest. Entries for the readers’ choice event are soon. And although one of the winner’s perks – recognition at the DFW Writers Conference – will be missing, a victim of the current pandemic, there’s still plenty to gain. 

The top 30 submissions, as determined by Hammons’ volunteer crew of slushpile readers, will receive feedback from online readers. And the surviving finalists will get eyes on their writing samples from publishing industry pros. 

This year I return as one of those slush readers winnowing the initial entrants. We joined Hammons recently on Twitter to share the secrets of what it takes to win our hearts. I’ll recap while expanding on my own preferences. Pay attention – you may just find yourself in the winner’s circle!

It shouldn't need saying but I will -- contestants must produce a strong writing sample.

Over and over, slushpile readers made statements such as, “Writing quality is my highest weighted category. A really well-written piece can make up for other things I might not like.” 

And, “Give me a STRONG hook! I cannot stress this enough. Grab me before my mind and wander and don’t let me go until the end.” 

Or, “Great writing is my number one criteria. I know that’s subjective, but for me it’s about whether your story draws me in: is your dialogue realistic, do you have the right blend of dialogue, emotions, action, and world building.” 

And with a 500-word limit on entries, every blow – I mean word – has to punch above its weight.

“What’s the key to my vote?” another slushpile reader tweeted. “It’s really, really, simple: tight writing. SUPER tight. No dramatics, no clichés. I don’t even care what genre; a strong premise is only a bonus. I just want to know you can tell a story.” 

So, does a 500-word limit mean the contest is limited to flash fiction? Not at all. Flash is perfectly OK, but those of the 30 original contestants who make it through the early rounds of reader feedback will be expected to produce additional – and longer – writing samples. This probably explains why most of the entries I’ve seen so far appear to be excerpts from longer works. 

But as I’ve told my own critique group, the writing sample doesn’t have to be verbatim from a longer piece. Choosing which elements are essential and which can be temporarily dispensed with is an art. What I’ve seen a little too much of, both this year and last, when I also read slush, is the lack of arc. There may be lyrical writing or great character sketches, but even with only a fragment of scene, the sample has to show a potential to go somewhere, to have legs.

As a fellow slushie tweeted, “A gripping first sentence does a lot for me, but something has to actually happen in the story. It can’t just be all exposition.” 

Other tweets – “I was glued to the story. . .” 

“The writer managed to get into my head. . .” 

“Make me forget about #COVID-19. Even if only for a few minutes. Give me a story that will consume my mind and emotions with something else.” 

So, you’ve got a strong opening, a gripping middle. . . how about that ending? Remembering it’s not necessarily the ending of the entire story, only of this 500-word fragment. 

Slushies say, “Bonus points for a surprise ending. . . I really LOVE surprise endings.” And, “One of my favorites so far had a fantastic twist at the end. I want to know what happens!” And, “If it’s not a short (story) with closure, I need at least a signpost or tip of the hat as to where the author is taking me.” 

A slushpile reader quoted earlier not caring about genre, but some do pine for more variation in genres. Admittedly, with most entries expected in this final week, it’s still surprising that I’ve counted fewer than a half-dozen YA submissions. 

Other slushies tweeted, “I’d love to see some nonfiction and memoirs,” and “I wouldn’t mind seeing more horror entries. . . hint, hint.” (Although as another noted, “I like my horror IMPLIED, not graphic or gory!” Slushpile readers also like humor, either as a stand-alone genre or sprinkled into other genres. And speaking personally, I’m a sucker for mysteries, historicals, and thrillers. 

And although great writing is tops on we slushies’ lists of must-haves, we’re not immune to pickier issues. “Suck me in, trap me, make me care,” one tweeted. “I’m more lax on grammar. I’ll even skip over it if I’m engrossed but if it comes down to a submission with good grammar vs. one with not-go-good. . .” 

And, “If I’m debating between two great pieces, proper grammar can tip the scales.” And another, “I’m not a huge stickler for grammar mistakes, but it if keeps pulling out of the story? It will affect my vote at that point.” 

So, there you have it, writers! Great writing, strong beginning, a story arc with strong ending. And don’t ignore your word processor’s grammar suggestions. 

*** 

Another popular post of 2020 was the following, dealing with the Twitter-based #10Queries online contest. I haven’t seen a date for 2021 yet, but most likely it will occur this coming February. 

What can we learn from #10Queries feedback? 

Why is hearing takes on other writers’ queries so much less painful than writing our own? Thank dog the editors’ posts from Revise & Resub’s recent #10Queries competition were anonymous! And though it sometimes seemed as if, for every 10 editors in a room there were 20 answers on how to write a perfect query, some issues in the submitted query letters appeared often enough to generate consensus. 

Issues such as: conflict – whether it’s a fistfight or a galactic war. And stakes – what will be gained or lost by the conflict. Conflict and stakes are the heart of stories, but one editor after another posted comments like: “conflict is unclear. What’s at stake?” Or, “motivation and stakes for the main character need to be upped. What are the personal stakes if they don’t succeed?” Or, “focus on conflict and stakes and what makes them unique.” 

But can’t a writer just narrate to the reader – agent or editor – what happens in the novel? Won’t that cover the issues of conflict and stakes? 

Sorry, as any reader of this blog – or attendee at the Dallas-Fort Worth Writers Conference’s infamous query gong shows knows -- spending significant query real estate on plot still may not make clear why the characters are running around like Energizer bunnies. 

#10Queries editors weren’t as brutal as agents at the gong show contest about saying that what they read was sometimes too darn long. Instead, they used more diplomatic language such as “heavy on setup and introducing characters but. . .” And “too many details about the story but at the same time is too vague on the important points.” Or, “feels more like narrative than tight, concise query.” Or the just plain, “simplify.” 

So far, it may sound as if the editors were focused on the what than the who of authors’ queries. Not so. Remember those “personal stakes” mentioned earlier? So, editors also included such comments as, “give us more of (the main characters’) motivation,” and “tell us why they care about the particular event in the query.” Or, “Clear goals but no motive. . . goals are nothing if the character doesn’t have a reason for the goal.” 

Editors also wanted to meet the characters who have those goals right away. One gave a “hm” to a writer who didn’t mention the main character until the second paragraph (but recovered with sharp voice and wit). 

And while editors loved characters who “feel so authentic,” they could also say, “make it clearer who the main character is.” 

And on the issue of the unlikable character one editor noted, “the woe-is-me character right from the get-go makes him a bit unlikable. . . I want an emotional connection before I can agree that him dying would be a bad idea.” 

One editor also posted a “random thought” about two issues that have always bothered me – “the importance of hooks and comp titles.” 

Image: Pixabay
Obviously, a hook is something that will immediately catch a reader’s attention, but what does it take to do that? As someone who’s tried starting with action only to receive a “meh” response, I dug further and found this answer (of a sort) at the site Literary Devices: “. . . not all hooks are based in action. They can also present a character, or group of characters with interesting traits, a thematic opening statement, or a mysterious and intriguing setting.” 

Beware though – in a query letter, that hook had better be short! 

And comp – that is, comparison – titles? Editors at #10Queries could say that a writer’s comps were “amazing!” as well as note that they were “a bit unfamiliar.” 

Probably like most writers, I feel that my stories are unique. What can we possibly find to compare them to? The Reedsy blog, among other resources, makes suggestions, including dos and don’ts for comp titles. 

My personal suggestions are to check our Goodreads follow-ups of the “you finished X, now what” variety, and Amazon’s listing of books bought by those who read the books we loved to read. And then, of course, to actually look at the suggested books. 

I’ll close with the easy stuff from the #10Queries editors, but not so easy that I didn’t have fails in this area. Remember that it’s the writing that counts, not the clothes it wears. Don’t make the query, as one editor noted, “difficult on the eye,” with small fonts and chunks of italics. Don’t forget to include age group, genre, word count and title – the last in all capitals. 

But wait -- here’s the real closer – the submissions window for #RevPit, Revise & Resub’s annual contest on Twitter (usually open in April). Put what we’ve learned into practice and save the date! 

Monday, April 13, 2020

What WRiTE CLUB slushpile readers want to see!

It’s crunch time for submissions to the 2020 edition (and ninth year!) of DL Hammons WRiTE CLUB contest. Entries for the readers’ choice event are due this coming Sunday, April 19. And although one of the winner’s perks – recognition at the DFW Writers Conference – will be missing, a victim of the current pandemic, there’s still plenty to gain.

The top 30 submissions, as determined by Hammons’ volunteer crew of slushpile readers, will receive feedback from online readers. And the surviving finalists will get eyes on their writing samples from publishing industry pros. 

This year I return as one of those slush readers winnowing the initial entrants. We joined Hammons recently on Twitter to share the secrets of what it takes to win our hearts. I’ll recap while expanding on my own preferences. Pay attention – you may just find yourself in the winner’s circle!

It should not need saying but I will -- contestants need to produce a strong writing sample. 
image: pixabay

Over and over, slushpile readers made statements such as, “Writing quality is my highest weighted category. A really well-written piece can make up for other things I might not like.” 

And, “Give me a STRONG hook! I cannot stress this enough. Grab me before my mind and wander and don’t let me go until the end.”

Or, “Great writing is my number one criteria. I know that’s subjective, but for me it’s about whether your story draws me in: is your dialogue realistic, do you have the right blend of dialogue, emotions, action, and world building.”

And with a 500-word limit on entries, every blow – I mean word – has to punch above its weight. 

“What’s the key to my vote?” another slushpile reader tweeted. “It’s really, really, simple: tight writing. SUPER tight. No dramatics, no clichés. I don’t even care what genre; a strong premise is only a bonus. I just want to know you can tell a story.”

So, does a 500-word limit mean the contest is limited to flash fiction? Not at all. Flash is perfectly OK, but those of the 30 original contestants who make it through the early rounds of reader feedback will be expected to produce additional – and longer – writing samples. This probably explains why most of the entries I’ve seen so far appear to be excerpts from longer works. 

But as I’ve told my own critique group, the writing sample doesn’t have to be verbatim from a longer piece. Choosing which elements are essential and which can be temporarily dispensed with is an art. What I’ve seen a little too much of, both this year and last, when I also read slush, is the lack of arc. There may be lyrical writing or great character sketches, but even with only a fragment of scene, the sample has to show a potential to go somewhere, to have legs.

As a fellow slushie tweeted, “A gripping first sentence does a lot for me, but something has to actually happen in the story. It can’t just be all exposition.”

Other tweets – “I was glued to the story. . .”

“The writer managed to get into my head. . .” 

And, “Make me forget about #COVID-19. Even if only for a few minutes. Give me a story that will consume my mind and emotions with something else.”

So, you’ve got a strong opening, a gripping middle. . . how about that ending? Remembering it’s not necessarily the ending of the entire story, only of this 500-word fragment. 

Slushies say, “Bonus points for a surprise ending. . . I really LOVE surprise endings.” And, “One of my favorites so far had a fantastic twist at the end. I want to know what happens!” And, “If it’s not a short (story) with closure, I need at least a signpost or tip of the hat as to where the author is taking me.”

A slushpile reader quoted earlier not caring about genre, but some do pine for more variation in genres. Admittedly, with most entries expected in this final week, it’s still surprising that I’ve counted fewer than a half-dozen YA submissions. 

Other slushies tweeted, “I’d love to see some nonfiction and memoirs,” and “I wouldn’t mind seeing more horror entries. . . hint, hint.” (Although another noted, “I like my horror IMPLIED, not graphic or gory!” Slushpile readers also like humor, either as a stand-alone genre or sprinkled into other genres. And speaking personally, I’m a sucker for mysteries, historicals, and thrillers.

And although great writing is tops on we slushies’ lists of must-haves, we’re not immune to pickier issues. “Suck me in, trap me, make me care,” one tweeted. “I’m more lax on grammar. I’ll even skip over it if I’m engrossed but if it comes down to a submission with good grammar vs. one with not-go-good. . .”

And, “If I’m debating between two great pieces, proper grammar can tip the scales.” And another, “I’m not a huge stickler for grammar mistakes, but it if keeps pulling out of the story? It will affect my vote at that point.”

So, there you have it, writers! Great writing, strong beginning, a story arc with strong ending. And don’t ignore your word processor’s grammar suggestions. Now hie thee to the WRiTE CLUB site and enter!